I have no doubt that the release of episode 3 of the Star Wars prequel trilogy must be the most blogged about topic on the Internet this week. And I’m also not sure that I could possibly be adding to anything that hasn’t been said before, but nevertheless I want to share my own opinion(s) with the world.
Before I go any further, let me give a spoiler warning now. I’m not going to pussyfoot around the topics I saw on the screen. Some may be spoilers, some may seem irrelevant. Either way, if you haven’t seen the film yet and you want to be surprised you might be better off by stopping here and redirecting your attention to another web site.
Okay, so I saw the film on opening weekend, which means I was relatively early but not among the costume-wearing crowd. I have seen each of the other five in theater so I guess you could say I’m a big Star Wars fan, and it stands to reason that I had high hopes for this film. After all, this was supposed to bridge the gap.
Episode three was the perfect opportunity to fill in all those details that true Star Wars fans know, and that everyone else is lost on. If not here, there would never be another opportunity to put on screen some timeline events like:
- the Millenium Falcon making the Kessel Run
- Han Solo saving Chewbacca’s life
- Han Solo dumping the shipment he was smuggling for Jabba
- Boba Fett’s involvement in the Han Solo-Jabba The Hut story
- Lando Calrissian’s place in the story
- why Yoda chose Dagobah and what’s in that cave
- the origin of the name “Ben” Kenobi
- how Leia came to be a Princess
Indeed, what better place for all of these elements? Except that they weren’t there. None.
Now to be fair, there were a number things that were explained, such as: the end of the Republic and birth of the Empire; how the Emperor got to look so disgusting and evil; how Anakin became Darth Vader and why he’s more machine than man; why Luke and Leia didn’t know each other and why Vader didn’t know either of them; C3P0’s lack of memory and R2D2’s claims of belonging to Obi-Wan; and why Yoda and Obi-Wan were in hiding. Those details are appreciated, but if they weren’t there, you wouldn’t have a movie at all. It needed more.
As it is, I feel like I’m watching a cartoon for two hours. I would have said “video game”, but I honestly feel like modern video games have better graphics. All of the magic Lucas created for Star Wars, Empire, and Jedi has been tragically missing from the prequel trilogy and that was never more evident than in the dark final chapter here.
For twenty years, I’ve reminisced fondly about the haunting choir of male voices in their almost Gregorian chant as Luke Skywalker beats relentlessly upon Darth Vader in their final duel. I’ve loved the dramatic genious of the heavy shadows on Lukes face as he hid beneath the catwalk while Vader searched for him. I’ve appreciated the use of mixed lighting from the original trilogy where warm lights came from interior and cool lights were used from exterior locations to create a realistic mixed lighting feeling as characters walked in front of the windows on their ships.
But these things were all missing in Revenge of the Sith. Instead of a dark, foreboding chorus when Obi-Wan fought Vader, we were blasted with trumpet staccatos and fanfares. With all the overuse of rendered scenery and green-screens, mixed lighting was apparently not an option. And the thing I continue to hate about digitally rendered video is the excessive shadow detail that just doesn’t look dramatic — too much visual information reduces the impact of a scene.
Then there’s the acting. Hayden Christensen irritated me in Clones but while he’s still annoying, he actually seems to have improved a bit for this film. His counterpart, Natalie Portman, wasn’t too bad in Episode One but I can’t help feeling that her talents have declined over the course of these three movies. Ian McDiarmid was excellent as the Emperor in Empire and Jedi, and good as the Senator/Chancellor in the prequel trilogy, but his acting in Sith was spotty — superb as the Chancellor in the beginning, but lousy in the scene where Mace Windu comes to kill him as well as in the battle with Yoda.
Over the course of these three movies, the acting talent has been sparse. Samuel Jackson is a great actor whose on-screen presence is just too brief in each case to be appreciated. Jimmy Smits is just as talented and had even less screen time. Liam Neeson has possibly had the best Star Wars screen presence since Harrison Ford, and was rewarded by having his character killed off.
Thus, the only true bright spot has been Ewan McGregor. With each episode of the trilogy, McGregor has grown more and more indistinguishable from Sir Alec Guiness. His accent seems to echo that of the old Obi-Wan. And his mannerisms are a perfect reenactment of Guiness. If Han Solo carried the original trilogy, Obi-Wan carried the recent trilogy.
With the wealth of experienced actors surrounding him this time around (unlike the original films) it’s hard to imagine so many uninteresting portrayals. Much of the blame has to be cast at the directing. A director should be demanding of his cast, but it really just felt like Lucas too readily accepted the first take rather than reshooting until it was right.
But his failures as a director don’t stop there. Revenge of the Sith is bloated, just as Menace and Clones were. There are too many irrelevant scenes left in that slow the story. I hate to admit that after all the anticipation and excitement, I almost fell asleep during this movie. That should not happen.
Just like the Matrix and Lord of the Rings sequels, I felt like this movie was nothing but jump cuts from action scene to action scene. Hollywood has become too dependant on action and effects, at the cost of good storytelling.
Ultimately, watching Revenge of the Sith felt like watching someone play with a new toy. It didn’t feel like watching the culmination of a filmmakers dream after a quarter of a century. Lucas started in the middle, and filmed A New Hope first, because it was important to him to give the audience a good story. Conversely, I can’t help feeling like Revenge of the Sith was made just to show off his new computers. It’s a huge disappointment, making it the fitting end to a disappointing trilogy that turned a filmmaking God into just another Hollywood chump.