I love reading about personal finance, simplifying life, and even being frugal — I’ve got dozens of related feeds in my Google Reader — but sometimes these people go a bit too far. And I’ve got a beef with Flexo’s 10 reasons not to go to the gym at Consumerism Commentary:
1. Most new memberships in January will cancel by April. That’s a lot of New Year’s Resolutions gone bad.
2. There is bacteria everywhere, including on the equipment and in the locker room towels.
3. Gyms aren’t equipped to handle health emergencies.
4. People don’t need any type of certification to become trainers, and they may not know much more than you.
5. They make it very difficult to quit membership. If you don’t pay, they may report you to credit reporting agencies even if you claim you canceled your membership.
6. There are catches in the fine print of the membership contract.
7. Gyms aren’t required to maintain their equipment, so there can be a danger in operating the equipment.
8. You can negotiate your membership rates by paying attention to specials offered throughout the year.
9. The lockers in which you leave your personal belongings can be robbed, and the gym is not held liable.
10. By joining or even entering a gym, you generally sign a waiver that relieves the company of any liability.
Seriously people? Are you honestly trying to make an argument to keep Americans out of the gym? We’re not fat enough already?
Let’s look at this bad logic item by item:
Bad reason #1: 1. Most new memberships in January will cancel by April. That’s a lot of New Year’s Resolutions gone bad.
Okay, and most new businesses fail within the first year. Should I not bother trying to start a business either? Hey… did you know that 65% of new marriages fail? By Flexo’s reasoning, that means nobody should get married, either.
I have a problem with people using generic terms like “most” and “a lot” in these arguments. How about some hard numbers?
Or how about a different perspective… some of these people do stick to their workout. If even one life is improved, what’s the problem?
Bad reason #2: There is bacteria everywhere, including on the equipment and in the locker room towels.
There’s bacteria on the door at the 7-Eleven, too. And what about the shopping carts where you buy your groceries? In fact, speaking of groceries, how many old ladies have picked up and handled that apple you’re about to put in your mouth? Good heavens… the germs are going to kill us all! Time to start wearing masks and gloves everywhere. Hey, and how about a nice tinfoil hat, too!
Look. You’re not going to the gym to lick the weight bench… you’re there to get a workout. And the nice thing about the gym is that there’s a shower there. With soap. You’ll leave there cleaner than you were when you arrived.
Bad reason #3: Gyms aren’t equipped to handle health emergencies.
Neither is the city bus you ride, but you manage to get by just fine. The park your kids are playing at doesn’t have a nurse on staff, yet if little Johnny falls off the slide and scrapes his arm, you manage to get it dealt with. And frankly, if a health emergency did occur at a gym, you’d be surrounded by people who would help you… which is much better than your odds at home!
Bad reason #4: People don’t need any type of certification to become trainers, and they may not know much more than you.
Yup. There are lots of jobs you can get that don’t require certification. (Remember that horse groomer who used to be the head of FEMA?)
The nice thing about trainers is that looks are everything. If a fat guy tells you how you should eat, are you going to listen? It’s just like the high school woodshop teacher who was missing a finger. If the trainer is in good shape and you’re not, odds are that he knows something you don’t.
Bad reason #5: They make it very difficult to quit membership. If you don’t pay, they may report you to credit reporting agencies even if you claim you canceled your membership.
To be honest, this sounds like Flexo had a bad experience, and he’s applying that as a prejudice against all gyms. Besides… if you don’t pay your bills, you shouldn’t be surprised if it gets reported to credit agencies.
Yes, I’ll admit that there is an overall sense that gyms don’t make it easy to quit. But this is a victim mentality. The membership representatives have an incentive to keep you, and they’re going to ask you the questions that any salesman would ask you: Why do you want to quit? Is there something we can do to keep you? Don’t you want to be healthy any more?
The reason people have a hard time quitting is because these questions play to the lies people tell themselves. Everyone wants to believe that they’re concerned about their health. Nobody wants to admit that they are too lazy to show up and work out. The only reason you want to cancel your membership is because you finally realized that purchasing a membership does not, by itself, get you into shape. You have to actually do work.
If you’re committed to being fat and lazy, just own up to it. Walk into the rep’s office, look him dead in the eye, and say, “I am a fat, lazy slob. I have learned that about myself, and I’m not going to change. Your policy requires 30 days notice on cancellation of membership, so this is my notice. Give me a document that proves you have acknowledged my desire to terminate my membership.”
Ironically, however, if you can man up enough to say that, you could probably man up enough to use the membership and actually get some benefit. The reason it’s hard to quit is the same reason the membership isn’t working: you don’t have any balls.
Bad reason #6: There are catches in the fine print of the membership contract.
Only an idiot signs his name to something he has not read. If there was something in there that you consider to be “a catch”, you shouldn’t have joined in the first place. See #5 above.
Bad reason #7: Gyms aren’t required to maintain their equipment, so there can be a danger in operating the equipment.
If a gym had poorly maintained equipment, you should have noticed that on your tour before you joined. If the equipment has gone bad over time, you should leave and find a new gym. This guy has a serious victim mentality, and he’s just making excuses now.
Anyway, what is there to maintain? There are no moving parts on barbells, dumbells, weight benches, or power racks. If you’re using the isolation exercise machines (like Nautilus) you’re already risking injury even on a brand new machine. And if it’s the stairmaster or the treadmill you’re complaining about, you’re just a whiner. Save the gym membership and just go climb some stairs. Or go for a walk. Anyway, how are you going to injure yourself on a treadmill? That would be a YouTube gem for sure!
Bad reason #8: You can negotiate your membership rates by paying attention to specials offered throughout the year.
This isn’t a reason to avoid the gym, it’s just an unrelated fact. And you can always negotiate your membership. Don’t believe me? Just go tell the rep that you want to quit. (See #5 above.) Let’s be honest here… this was just thrown in because he couldn’t think of anything to get his list to the nice round number 10.
Bad reason #9: The lockers in which you leave your personal belongings can be robbed, and the gym is not held liable.
Hello, McFly! They’re called LOCK-ers. You are supposed to LOCK them. Once locked in a locker, your property is every bit as safe as it would be in your car.
Let’s get real. I go to the gym every morning, five days a week, and I see what people do. They use the lockers without locking them. They take off their clothes (and iPods) and leave them in a pile on the floor while they hit the showers. Oh, and they also just have stupid moments and forget things.
If you’re putting your valuables into the locker, and locking it, they will be there when you are done.
Bad reason #10: By joining or even entering a gym, you generally sign a waiver that relieves the company of any liability.
As opposed to your home gym? Seriously? His final argument is that he wants someone to sue if he hurts himself? Am I understanding this correctly?
It is not the gym’s fault that you don’t pay attention to proper technique. It is not the gym’s fault that you and your friends want to impress each other with weights you have no business lifting. It is not the gym’s fault that you injured yourself on a treadmill (seriously… a YouTube gem).
Seriously. What’s with all the anti-gym rhetoric lately on all of the personal finance blogs?
[EDIT: I errantly attributed these opinions to Flexo, the author of the post I linked to. The list was actually copied out of SmartMoney. Still, we don’t repost things we disagree with.]